This is probably a portrait of Alberto Luhan who posed for Sharp in the nude during the summer of 1915 and appeared in several larger compositions including The Old War Shield. (related image, #360) A painting titled The Mystery of Fire was presented at the galleries of the Hotel Gibson in Cincinnati in 1919. This could be that work.
See also a similar study in size, subject and composition, Beside the Teepee’s Blaze. (related image, #662)
The Mystery of Fire, Black Deer
Alternate Title: Indian Firelight
Record ID: 690
Date: ca. 1915
Medium: oil on canvas
Dimensions: 16 x 20 in.
Signature / Inscription: LL: J.H.SHARP
Owner: Stark Museum of Art, Orange, TX
Accession Number: 31.25.78
Provenance: The artist; [?]; H.J. Lutcher Stark; present owner: Nelda C. and H.J. Lutcher Stark Foundation, Orange, Texas, by bequest, 1999; accession to Stark Museum of Art
Related